There is broad consensus on the need to build a more diverse and robust teacher pipeline, but strategies to guide those who show early interest in this profession remain limited. A working paper by Danielle Sanderson Edwards and Matthew A. Kraft sought to examine the effect of education courses taken during high school on the teacher pipeline, including on the diversity of teachers.
Early interest in professions among adolescents is highly predictive of future career choices, so many states and districts have sought to foster early interest in the teaching profession. In particular, the creation of education courses taken during high school is a common grow-your-own recruitment effort; these classes aim to produce and sustain interest among high school students.
Using data for Texas K–12 students, teachers, and postsecondary students from 2004–22, the authors assess the effectiveness of such courses by tracking employment as a Texas K–12 public school teacher within 11 years of starting ninth grade. They identify four key findings: (1) greater access to such courses in high school resulted in greater enrollment in the courses, but was unlikely to increase the probability of becoming a teacher; (2) there was greater gender variation than racial variation in student enrollment in courses; (3) the majority of education course takers exited the pipeline prior to college; and (4) course takers who became teachers had similar effectiveness but higher retention rates compared to other teachers.
Increased access to education courses during high school resulted in a 3-percentage-point increase in enrollment for the full sample and over 5 percentage points for women. Yet there’s little evidence that this access increased the probability of becoming a teacher in Texas regardless of student demographics.
While 61 percent of sampled students had access to high school education courses, only 4.2 percent of students at schools offering the courses ever took one. Three-quarters of high school education course takers were female, suggesting that the teaching gender gap started before high school. Enrollment rates across Black, Hispanic, and White students were similar while Asian students tended not to enroll in these courses.
Although course takers become teachers at quadruple the rate of other students, less than 10 percent do, and the majority of those initially interested in the profession exit the pipeline. Only 31 percent of education course takers enroll in a Texas public four-year college within seven years of ninth grade, and a quarter of this population, 7.7 percent of education course takers, enter an undergraduate teacher certification program. Across all high school education course takers, only 3.2 percent of male students become teachers compared to 10 percent of female students. White course takers become teachers at more than twice the rate of Black and Hispanic course takers, reflecting racial gaps in four-year college enrollment that were not evident in high school education course enrollment.
After the first year of teaching, 93 percent of education course takers remained in the profession the next year compared with 86 percent of other first-year teachers, and course takers also had higher three-year retention rates.
These findings suggest that offering education courses to high school students is unlikely to increase teacher supply, as most high school education course takers exit the pipeline before college enrollment. Still, the authors note, interest in teaching may be higher than perceived. Course enrollment is similar across racial groups, suggesting that racial gaps may reflect differences in educational attainment, whereas gender gaps arise prior to high school. Additionally, although the courses may not directly expand the teacher pipeline, those who participate and become teachers may have a deeper and more lasting commitment to the profession.
This study provides some of the first evidence on the limited effectiveness of high school education courses and the value of targeting adolescent interest as a recruitment mechanism. It also extends research on the “leaky” teacher pipeline, which often focuses on undergraduate programs, to earlier stages. Participants in high school education programs and those with early interest in the profession may be more likely to persist if they become teachers, so more supports are needed to target and guide those exiting the pipeline towards completing the necessary requirements to become a teacher. The modest impact of high school education courses on the teacher pipeline signals the need for additional recruitment mechanisms that translate to a larger supply of diverse and committed teachers.
Source: Danielle Sanderson Edwards and Matthew A. Kraft, Can Early Exposure to the Teaching Profession Increase Teacher Supply and Diversity? New Evidence on the Teacher Pipeline (EdWorkingPaper, 2026).