Skip to main content

Mobile Navigation

  • National
    • Policy
      • High Expectations
      • Quality Choices
      • Personalized Pathways
    • Research
    • Commentary
      • Gadfly Newsletter
      • Flypaper Blog
    • Events
    • Scholars Program
  • Ohio
    • Policy
      • Priorities
      • Media & Testimony
    • Research
    • Commentary
      • Ohio Education Gadfly Biweekly
      • Ohio Gadfly Daily
  • Charter Authorizing
    • Application
    • Sponsored Schools
    • Resources
  • About
    • Mission
    • Board
    • Staff
    • Career
Home
Home
Advancing Educational Excellence

Main Navigation

  • National
  • Ohio
  • Charter Authorizing
  • About

National Menu

  • Topics
    • Accountability & Testing
    • Advanced Education
    • Career & Technical Education
    • Charter Schools
    • Curriculum & Instruction
    • ESSA
    • Evidence-Based Learning
    • Facilities
    • Governance
    • Personalized Learning
    • Private School Choice
    • School Finance
    • Standards
    • Teachers & School Leaders
    • Think Again
  • Research
  • Commentary
    • Gadfly Newsletter
    • Flypaper Blog
    • Gadfly Podcast
  • Events
  • Scholars Program
Listen on Apple Podcasts Listen on Spotify Watch on YouTube
Podcast

Ed reform is hard. It’s still worth the political fight. | Episode 1043 of The Education Gadfly Show

Michael J. Petrilli David Griffith, Ph.D. Brian R. Fitzpatrick, Ph.D.
11.18.2026
 

Mike Petrilli is back for another solo episode, and he isn’t done talking politics just yet. Following last week’s episode on the survival of ed reform after the blue wave, Mike takes an even closer look at the political costs of education reform, from school turnarounds in Houston to universal school choice and ESAs in Arizona and Texas. Why do reforms that sound popular in theory face so much backlash in practice? What will it take to keep education reform moving forward when doing the right thing isn’t always politically rewarding?

Then, on the Research Minute, Brian Fitzpatrick joins David Griffith to discuss a study examining the consequences of New York City’s ban on suspensions for minor infractions, including increased special education classifications and declining English language arts achievement among students with disabilities.

Recommended content:

  • School choice and the election: Pre-registering my take — Michael J. Petrilli, Thomas B. Fordham Institute
  • Election reflections — Michael J. Petrilli, Thomas B. Fordham Institute
  • Transforming school systems | Episode 1028 of The Education Gadfly Show — Mike Miles, The Education Gadfly Show
  • How to become an “education governor” in 2026 — Chad Aldeman, Thomas B. Fordham Institute
  • Disability as Discipline? Effects of the New York City Suspension Ban on Students With Disabilities — Jo R. King, Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 2026

Feedback Welcome: Have ideas for improving our show? We would love to hear them. Send them to [email protected]


One quick correction: We referred to Jo R. King using the wrong pronouns during today’s Research Minute. Jo uses they/them pronouns. We regret the error.

This transcript was generated with the assistance of AI and lightly edited for clarity and readability.

Transcript

Introduction

Stephanie Distler [00:00]

Welcome to The Education Gadfly Show.

I'm Stephanie Distler, producer of the show here at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute.

This week, Mike Petrilli is back with another solo episode, and he's not quite done talking politics.

Following last week's discussion of the blue wave, Mike examines the political costs of education reform, from school turnarounds in Houston to school choice programs in Arizona and Texas.

Then on the Research Minute, Brian Fitzpatrick joins David Griffith to discuss the unintended consequences of New York City's ban on suspensions for minor infractions.

All that and more this week on The Education Gadfly Show.

Ed Reform Update: The political costs of education reform

Mike Petrilli [00:53]

Hello, this is your host, Mike Petrilli of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, here at The Education Gadfly Show and online at FordhamInstitute.org.

It is, again, my monthly solo edition.

And of course, I'm going to talk about the election. What else?

It's November. Let's talk about that.

And of course, what it means for education reform.

We'll do that on Ed Reform Update.

All right, gang.

So, look, let me admit something that I find quite sobering.

Perhaps you will say either, duh, or you will say, Mike, don't say it out loud.

But here it is.

It's a secret.

Sometimes education reform is not very popular.

Okay.

Look, that is one takeaway I have from the election, and it's not a takeaway I really like.

Now, look, let's be clear.

A couple of things.

First of all, in this election, we all know that this blue wave, the blue tsunami, the blue-nami, that this was about one thing more than anything else, and that is Donald Trump.

This was a huge repudiation of him, of Trumpism, of the administration, of MAGA.

It reflected, you know, a lot of voters' anger at the cost of living, gasoline, inflation.

In the Midwest, you know, the concerns about fertilizer and tariffs.

You know, this basic concern that voters are hurting, they're having a hard time keeping up with the rising cost of living, and they feel like politicians, especially Trump and the Republicans, are not doing enough to address it.

You know, along with concerns around corruption and immigration and all the rest that we've lived through over the last two years.

That is mostly what this is about.

And that tsunami swept Democrats in all over the country and, of course, is going to have big implications for those of us in education reform because a bunch of states went blue or they went from purple or blue to deep blue.

And we will talk about that.

But that does not mean that education was the reason that that happened, that for the most part, you know, education was, as has been the case now for a while, a bit player in this election.

It is also the case that if you poll various reform issues, there are plenty that poll well, right?

Charter schools, depending on how you define them, people like.

Even school choice, again, depending on how you describe it, people like.

Even the word accountability, right, which we will talk about today.

You know, in theory, people like, oh yeah, I want our schools to be held accountable.

Yeah, I'm for that.

Right?

And of course, there's a bunch of things that reformers care about that are not super unpopular or controversial.

Things like spending more money, which some of us support, or raising teacher salaries or, you know, doing the sort of instructional reforms to improve reading and math.

That stuff is popular as well.

Okay, but the question that I have and I want to talk about today is whether efforts to actually do something in the face of chronic low performance, like we've seen in Texas, especially in Houston and more recently Fort Worth, and there was going to be a bunch of other places, that kind of stuff where you come in and actually try to make change, ruffle feathers, that's hard.

In many cases, that is unpopular.

Private school choice, especially if it's universal school choice so that even the wealthy families get the money, money to send their kids to private schools that do not welcome everybody's children, or education savings accounts like we see in Arizona, where there's just this drip, drip, drip of news of people spending the money on dubious things, trips to Walt Disney World and trampolines and all the rest, again, including wealthy families getting government money to do that.

That creates problems.

And while those were not at the center of the election, I do think they were a factor in a few places.

Now, so let's talk about that piece.

I said before the election, it was actually on Election Day, but before we knew how things were going to go, I preregistered my thoughts on how we would be convinced if education was actually a big factor in this election, especially, for example, the issue of school choice.

Right?

And the reason I thought this was important was because I knew that people were going to be spinning the results one way or another.

I mean, this is how issue advocacy works, not just in education reform, in any issue.

Right?

That voucher opponents would want to spin the results of saying, see, vouchers are super unpopular and therefore, politicians, you should never vote in favor of them.

Right?

Voucher proponents would say, no, no, no, no, that wasn't a factor at all.

In fact, they're still quite popular.

Look at the polling.

Right?

Same could be said on other education issues.

Other issues writ large.

So I said in that piece, I said, look, you've got to really look at three things.

First of all, you've got to ask whether any given candidate outperformed what you would expect based on the overall national environment.

I mean, this was a crazy election.

We saw this huge shift from Republicans...

The Democrats won the House popular vote by 13 points.

Given that Trump had won by a point or two last time, that's a swing of 14 or 15 points.

People are saying you have to go back 50 years to look at that kind of a shift.

Enormous.

And in many cases, then, the folks who won some of these governor's races or the legislative chambers that flipped just represented this shift.

Right?

And they enjoyed the success from this blue wave.

But maybe if there's a candidate that did even better than that, right, that shifted their state even more dramatically, then there's a case that, okay, something that candidate did or said might have been a factor.

Right?

So then the second thing is to look and see: Did they make education reform a big issue or not in their campaign?

And then finally, were there other things that could explain it?

You know, this is sort of the Occam's razor, like, okay, are there obvious things that explain what was going on here as well in that given state?

In my opinion, there's only a few places that meet those tests.

Okay, the first is in Iowa with Rob Sand.

He crushed it.

I mean, man, he, I forget the final results, but I think maybe double digits.

He won big in a state that's, you know, if not red, at least pink.

And outperformed that tsunami by several points.

And he did certainly make education a significant part of his campaign.

Now, again, people in Iowa are mad about the price of diesel and fertilizer and tariffs and all the rest.

So it's not the only thing, but I think you could say that what he said on the campaign trail around private school choice, around it not being fair that these wealthy families get this money, that there's not enough accountability and regulation, maybe that moved a few voters.

Hard to tell, but I would buy that.

Likewise in Texas, Gina Hinojosa, again, outperformed this blue wave, and she certainly made education a big part of her campaign, both what she called the voucher scheme, as well as her anger over the turnaround in Houston and other places.

She promised to fire Mike Morath.

And look, I am sad about all of this.

I will say in Texas, I'm particularly sad about the Mike Morath part.

I think he's the best state superintendent we've got in the whole country.

And about the Houston part.

I'm a big fan of Mike Miles and what he's been trying to do in Houston.

I know it's not perfect, but it does seem to be making a difference.

And so I am sad to see that that attack on what was happening there was effective.

I have more mixed feelings about the private school choice program.

Okay, and here I got to be careful with what Matt Yglesias calls the pundit's fallacy.

The pundit's fallacy is saying that, hey, I'm a pundit and I'm going to tell you politicians that if you adopt my preferred policies, it will also help you get elected.

Right?

And sometimes that's true, but it's not always true.

Right?

And in my case, right, I'm saying that, hey, for example, I believe in accountability.

I believe in what was happening in Houston.

And maybe I have to admit that that did not help Governor Greg Abbott get reelected.

Right?

It may have helped him lose his job and Mike Morath lose their job.

On the voucher front, it's a little different.

I have been arguing for targeted school choice programs, for programs that have some degree of transparency and accountability.

And so I could say, well, Texas didn't follow my advice on that.

And so they reap the consequences.

So I know that I got to be careful about that because, of course, I would think that, right?

Hey, by the way, other states like Ohio and Georgia, I'm not as convinced that you can make the case that really school choice or education was a big factor there.

You know, Amy Acton in Ohio, I mean, big deal to win Ohio, but she didn't dramatically outperform, again, this blue wave.

She did by a little bit.

And we all know that her opponent ran a terrible campaign, especially at the end with that horrendous ad about her mother that he dropped.

So, you know, again, you can kind of explain that away, given that.

Likewise in Georgia with Keisha Lance Bottoms, it's hard to say that education was a huge factor there as far as I know.

Right?

Again, it doesn't mean that Amy Acton or Keisha Lance Bottoms didn't mention education or school choice.

They did.

And they talked about being opposed to it.

But I don't know that you can make the same case that it moved voters as you can in Texas and in Iowa.

Oh, and in Arizona.

And, you know, Arizona now goes from having a split divided government to having a Democratic trifecta and a Democratic state superintendent.

And the issue of its very lightly regulated universal education savings account has definitely been a big issue there.

So what does all this mean?

I mean, look, let's go to school choice here.

You know, what's interesting about the universal school choice programs in Texas and Arizona and elsewhere was that our friends on the right in the school choice movement made a decision about five or six years ago to go for universal programs because they thought that was going to be their best bet to actually get legislation passed.

You know, conventional wisdom used to be that, no, no, you would start with targeted programs for poor kids, working-class kids, maybe kids with disabilities, maybe other groups of kids like foster care kids who have particular challenges.

Those are the children for whom there's the broadest support for saying, hey, they are not getting the education they need, and providing them with these scholarships would allow them to get into better schools.

You could peel off certainly some Republican moderates, but also even some Democratic moderates, especially in the Black and Hispanic community.

And that worked for a while in a bunch of places.

And then it seemed to have not worked anymore, kind of hit a plateau.

And so there was this new red-state strategy that said, all right, well, forget about the targeting.

Forget about, you know, the talking points that are kind of making this case from an equity perspective.

Let's make the focus on universal, on everybody, including affluent families in the suburbs, including homeschoolers in rural areas.

That was key to try to get their representatives, Republican rural representatives, on board.

And let's see if we can get the big tent broader.

And it worked when it came to enacting programs.

We saw this whole wave of these newly enacted programs, mostly universal, mostly ESAs, and mostly throughout red-state America.

And so, you know, that was pretty impressive.

Even I had to admit it.

And folks who still care a lot about poor minority kids and other kids with disabilities would say, look, those kids will now benefit because their states have school choice programs that they would not have had if we kept trying this targeted approach that wasn't working.

Okay, but now fast-forward to today and what happens?

Well, that was a red-state strategy, and suddenly some of those red states are no longer red.

Okay?

Some of them are purple.

Some of them are, like Arizona, outright blue.

And so suddenly we're in this conundrum, right, that the folks that support private school choice have to play defense.

And we'll see how it goes.

And I think it's interesting that what I'm hearing as, what I guess in the early days of people playing defense is that the school choice proponents, guess who they're talking about?

Poor kids, working-class kids, kids with disabilities.

How dare you think about taking these scholarships away from these needy children?

Right?

Which makes sense.

That's the right argument to make, but it's interesting to me.

They, of course, can't make the argument that, hey, it's not fair to take this scholarship away from that family making half a million dollars a year.

Right?

Because that dog doesn't park.

Doesn't park?

No, that dog doesn't hunt.

And look, you know, Hinojosa and others were able to make this issue, they were able to connect it to these broader themes in their campaigns, to corruption, pay-to-play, to, you know, the rich people getting taken care of and getting favors while you, the working class, were struggling to put food on your table or afford health care.

Right?

Fair or not, you know, that populist message worked pretty well.

And so now school choice supporters have to figure out how to defend against that.

Now look, again, I got to be careful here because my own policy preferences.

It is also the case that there has been one time in America when a state created a school choice program, private school choice, and then repealed it.

And that was in Illinois, mostly in Chicago, in a very much a targeted program for poor kids.

Right?

And it was created under a rare Republican governor in Illinois, and then a Democratic governor came in, the current governor, J.B. Pritzker, and he and the Democratic legislature killed it.

Right?

So what does that show?

That even having, you know, these sympathetic recipients getting the scholarships, very poor kids in Chicago, was not enough to defend the program.

So I have to admit that maybe it wouldn't matter.

Right?

Maybe that doesn't help as much as I wish it would politically.

But, and we'll see.

Look, maybe in Arizona, you know, the school choice supporters will be able to defend the program, maybe in part because of the big tent.

I mean, you don't even hear Democrats in Arizona saying they are going to get rid of the program writ large.

They're talking about adding more regulations and oversight, maybe an income cap.

Same kinds of things you hear in Iowa.

You know, Gina Hinojosa is talking about getting rid of the Texas program, but she can't unilaterally because there's a Republican Senate.

So they will probably keep it alive, but again, maybe add some regulations.

So we'll know a lot more, I don't know, about six, seven, eight months from now when the next legislative sessions are over.

But for now, I think it's fair to say that this political strategy has some holes in it.

But so, too, on the accountability front, right?

You know, look, in Texas, it was many years ago that the Texas legislature passed a law about doing these state takeovers of chronically low-performing schools.

They started the clock and it was based on whether a district had any chronically low-performing F campuses.

And at some point, that clock ran out on Houston, Houston ISD.

And they had a whole bunch of F-rated schools and a mess.

I mean, you know, if you can remember those years, the school board was squabbling.

The district was in disarray.

I think a lot of leadership turnover.

I mean, a classic failing urban district that did not show any signs of turning around, serving, you know, what, almost 200,000 kids, most of them very poor, most of them Hispanic, some Black, but a group of kids that needed a great education.

And so following the law, and also because it was the right thing to do, the state commissioner, Mike Morath, I assume with the support of the governor, went in, appointed Mike Miles, and they did this big turnaround effort.

And hey, for sure, it made people angry.

You know, a lot of teachers got fired.

They had a new curriculum that a lot of people didn't like.

There were other changes that made people upset.

But change did happen.

And, you know, Mike, we had Mike on the show, I don't know, six months ago to talk about the changes.

I mean, root and branch, trying to overhaul that system, driving money to the low-income schools, paying teachers in those schools a lot more money, bringing in a strong instructional approach, lots of coaching.

Again, maybe not everybody's cup of tea.

And I know Mike Miles, as a West Point grad, is not everybody's cup of tea.

But man, did they do something?

They tried.

Right?

And now I worry that the message is, well, hey, if you're a politician, it's just not worth it because you're going to piss off so many people and they're going to get back at you the next time they get to vote.

I do worry about that.

I compare it to, say, New Hampshire, where they have a Republican governor that somehow survived the tsunami.

Now, she's only been in a couple of years.

Abbott had been in for three terms.

She was not a culture-warrior person like Abbott has been.

I mean, it's, you know, Texas and New Hampshire are very different places.

But my understanding is, you know, she hasn't ruffled a lot of feathers.

And so, you know, maybe going along to get along works pretty well politically.

Right?

Look, I remember a time, as I assume many of you do, when there were political incentives for both Democrats and Republicans to do the hard work of education reform.

Not just making the proposals that maybe sounded great at the beginning.

They always sound great at the beginning.

But to actually follow through and make change.

Right?

I mean, Bill Clinton was willing to go to bat for all these reforms.

And then George W. Bush, he did it in Texas.

And a big part of his pitch, first to the Republican Party and then to the country as a whole, was, hey, I'm going to take these Texas education reforms and bring them to Washington, D.C., and make them national.

And there was this sense that, you know, people would say, look, we're running against some of the people in our parties.

You know, Bill Clinton and even Barack Obama running against the unions on some of this stuff.

George W. Bush running against small-government conservatives who didn't want a strong federal role.

But they said, hey, this is necessary.

We got to do what's right for kids.

We got to, you know, the schools are not performing.

We got to do it.

We got to eat our broccoli.

Right?

And there were reasons to believe that voters would reward that, again, at least as reforms were getting underway.

They liked hearing that somebody had a can-do attitude and they were going to fix the schools and they were going to do things that were hard.

It certainly feels like we're in a different political era today, the populist era.

Maybe people don't want to hear that we have to do what's hard.

You know, maybe people are just too satisfied with their schools, or if they see problems, they blame it on anything but the school systems.

Or maybe we just need politicians who not only propose reforms, follow through with them, but are better at communicating them, at campaigning on them, at making the case for them.

You know, my sense is right now that the governor that's probably doing that best is Sarah Huckabee Sanders in Arkansas.

You know, came into office, passed a sweeping reform bill right away.

Has been busy implementing it with her great state superintendent, Jacob Oliva, and talks about it.

And, you know, when the test scores come out and they show some progress, she talks about it and she makes the case.

And there's some pain attached.

There's some tough things that she's trying to do, but she doesn't shy away from it.

Maybe Governor Abbott could have done more of that, you know, and maybe that's what it takes.

But maybe we also have to acknowledge that education reform is hard and it is not always going to be rewarding politically.

And we need to be honest with that about politicians.

We need to say this is something we want you to spend political capital on.

That means you might have to earn that political capital in other ways.

But it's worth it if you actually want to improve your schools, if you actually want to make your state's future brighter.

That's what it takes.

So I'm curious if you agree or if you think that it is possible without spinning to make a more positive pitch for education reform that is not just eat your broccoli.

Okay, gang, with that, now it's time for everyone's favorite, Amber's Research Minute.

Research Minute: New York City's suspension ban and special education

David Griffith [21:41]

Surprise!

There's no Amber.

There's also no Mike.

There's just David Griffith and Brian Fitzpatrick of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute.

Apparently, Amber is too busy to join us today.

And apparently, Brian, what I just heard is that Mike is too busy.

Between the Ed Reform Update and the Research Minute, he jetted off to Hawaii, of all places, I guess, to get some hard punditing in.

But anyway, how are you?

Welcome to the show.

Brian Fitzpatrick

I'm doing great.

I'm a little jealous of Mike getting to do some work and some play while in Hawaii, but I guess we can all go to Hawaii.

David Griffith

Yes, it's amazing.

We were only gone for a minute between these segments, and he managed to make it all the way to Hawaii.

I hear that next week's podcast may even be from Hawaii.

I have no idea what we're going to talk about.

Maybe it's a blue wave, although it seems like that has already crested in Hawaii.

But anyway, we are here to talk about research.

So why don't you tell us, Brian, what do you have for us today in this wonderful post-election, I won't say aftermath, but we'll just say this post-election era that we have?

Brian Fitzpatrick [22:58]

Well, actually, in this post-election era, we're going to talk about a paper that's going back over a decade now.

But it just came out two weeks ago in Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, a top-tier journal in education research.

It's by a scholar named Jo King out of Boston University.

And its title is Disability as Discipline: Effects of New York City's Suspension Ban on Students with Disabilities.

And so this is a paper that looks back at data from 2007 through 2015.

And right in the middle of that era, New York City issued a ban on suspensions for minor infractions.

And this paper looks at a kind of novel outcome of that ban, and that is the rate at which students get classified as having disabilities.

Her main finding is that in the aftermath of this ban, this is using longitudinal data, it's a difference-in-differences model.

It's a good longitudinal look, though it kind of falls short of the kind of top tier of causal evidence.

And she shows that in the aftermath of this ban, not only does the rate at which students are being classified as students with disabilities go up by about 22 percent, the change is concentrated in what she calls, what's the phrase she used?

Low-status disabilities versus high-status.

So low-status is like emotional disturbance, whereas high-status would be speech delay or autism spectrum disorder.

So she uses some kind of background work to show these are disabilities that are concentrated among disadvantaged kids.

And she shows that it's this kind of increase in students with disability status.

It's concentrated among Black and male students.

And finally, she shows in the aftermath of this suspension ban, the ELA scores of students with disabilities goes down by quite a bit.

Now, if you're like me, you wanted to know, okay, is that because these students at the margins, these new students getting pushed into special education, is it them who's suffering in their test scores?

And she's very cautious about what she can say around that.

In fact, she points to this evidence that, in fact, it's the students who are already special education where that ELA drop is really concentrated.

Now, I have some thoughts on that last finding, and there's a lot of new ones in this paper.

But before we dive in, do you have any questions or comments on the main findings?

David Griffith

Well, let me just make sure I'm getting it.

I think the subtext here is that kids with discipline issues are being pushed out of mainstream classrooms into more special ed environments, and that that is having sort of negative spillovers.

Is that fair?

Brian Fitzpatrick

Yes.

And that's in the aftermath of the ban on using suspensions in response to a whole category of misbehavior.

David Griffith

Okay.

No questions so far, except is there any but?

Brian Fitzpatrick

So I think the but comes in how you interpret it.

I actually found the author was very nuanced here.

She did say, you know, you could interpret this as just a positive change all around, where these students are kind of getting the right sort of interventions instead of exclusionary interventions.

She did mention the cost aspect, which is something I hadn't thought of until she mentioned it, which is suspending students doesn't cost any money.

Years of students being in special education cost the district quite a bit of money.

And this is a district that famously is seeing its cost per student go up and up and up.

The author is very careful to only portray students with behavioral issues, which, you know, this is common in academia, to only portray these students as being kind of victims and generally undeserving of punishment.

It kind of comes with those baseline assumptions.

I think we here at Fordham would be a little bit more open to the idea that these are students who are choosing to misbehave, and that we are reclassifying their misbehavior as kind of an exceptionality.

But that is just a kind of difference of interpretation rather than something that comes out of the data directly.

David Griffith

Okay.

Fair enough.

I don't really want to push back because this doesn't sound great, but I guess I'm just wondering.

I mean, I assume that the paper does not really get at, I guess there would potentially be benefits, right?

So, you know, the typical worry, right, is that if you keep kids who are disruptive in mainstream classrooms, that that will have a cost on mainstream students.

This is in some ways consistent with that, right?

Because it's saying if you put them in other classrooms, they will create costs for those students, I think.

But that sort of begs the question for me whether there are any benefits for the kids in the mainstream classrooms where these students are exiting.

Is there any attempt to get at that, or am I reading too much into it?

Brian Fitzpatrick

That's an interesting point I hadn't thought of.

There's no attempt to look at that specifically.

So this idea you're positing is essentially, this is a reshuffling of who's kind of dealing with the externalities of a misbehaving student.

That is very much in line with what she found, but she didn't specifically look at that.

David Griffith

Yeah.

I guess my other question is, I don't know, just trying to understand kind of, you know, how many suspensions we're avoiding here, right?

And how many kids we're talking about here, right?

It seems difficult to get at that.

But are we in a position to say, okay, this, you know, suspensions went down by this much, you know, as a fraction of total percentages, or these kids would have been suspended a certain number of times but were not?

Is there any way to put some numbers on any of this?

Brian Fitzpatrick

She cites some prior research that looked into it.

I didn't follow up by looking through those research papers.

She takes as a given that suspensions did in fact go down by quite a bit as a result of the ban.

I mean, you are banning them, so that sort of makes sense.

I don't have those numbers handy.

David Griffith

Okay.

What about sort of the number of kids that we're talking about here?

I mean, can we get any sense of it?

I mean, we are just talking about, we're not talking about every kid who might have been suspended here, right?

There are presumably some kids who stay in general ed classes and simply are not suspended.

Right?

Do we have a sense of sort of what the ratios are?

Or, you know, if you're a kid who would have received a suspension under the old policy, what are your chances of being reclassified?

And what are your chances of just, I don't know, staying in the general ed classroom, not being suspended?

The teacher finds some other...

Or what was your reading of it, Brian?

Brian Fitzpatrick

That's, we don't have numbers.

Yeah, that's a great question.

I'm looking at the tables now, and those, it looks like pre-ban, the percentage of...

Sorry, I don't mean to...

I don't really mean to cross-examine either.

No, we have to do some quick addition that's unwise for me to do on a podcast in order to get to that number.

It's in the tables.

We could get there.

It looks, you know, as ever, the small minority of students are getting suspended each year, and it looks like, you know, roughly 10 to 20 percent are in this category of would have gotten suspensions beforehand.

I'm not seeing the clear numbers on how much that changed before and after, but presumably you're right.

The number of students actually getting transferred into special education, I think it's a safe inference to say it's going to be only a small chunk of the students who were getting suspended for minor infractions before the ban.

I think we can take that as a safe assumption.

David Griffith

Yeah.

Okay.

And I guess the other thing, I mean, I'm still trying to wrap my head around all the questions that one would ideally answer, right, to resolve the issue, which we never will do, right?

But I think one question we do have the answer to here is, I mean, we're not seeing much academic benefit for this subset of kids who are no longer suspended.

Right?

In other words, they're not benefiting academically.

If you were going to sort of posit that there were benefits, they would either have to be for their peers who are staying in the sort of regular classrooms or maybe, you know, sort of more speculatively something on the criminal justice side.

But we don't get at that either, right?

Brian Fitzpatrick

Correct.

David Griffith

Gosh, it's almost hard to believe we haven't solved this one yet, Brian.

Brian Fitzpatrick

I should clarify, however, the author doesn't treat these as negative findings.

Right?

She treats essentially a reduction in exclusionary discipline, the author takes as kind of a huge win with some negative downsides.

David Griffith

Okay.

Brian Fitzpatrick

I don't know that I would interpret it that way, but it is a fair interpretation.

David Griffith

Right.

Well, I guess I want to know how you interpret it.

Brian Fitzpatrick

So, I don't take a reduction, in the same way that I don't take a kind of increase in high school graduation as a good thing a priori, I don't take a reduction in out-of-school suspensions as a good thing a priori.

Because my default is to assume that the high school, you know, this hypothetical high school who's getting near 100 percent graduation, has lowered their standards.

And that New York City schools over the course of this process, in fact, just lowered their behavioral standards.

And that we shouldn't even take as a benefit with downsides.

I wouldn't even call it a benefit on its own.

But those are deeply moralistic assumptions that portray kind of maybe the Fordham perspective or my perspective as being different than how many people approach these problems.

David Griffith

Yeah, I think it is kind of a Rorschach test.

As I wrote, it was one of my first Fordham columns where I said, basically, I'm annoyed with everybody, right?

People just walk into this debate and whatever they say says an awful lot about them and very little about the evidence.

I mean, it's interesting, right?

We have seen declines in suspensions, I think, across the country.

Both liberals and conservatives seem to have declared victory and think they've won the debate.

We've simultaneously seen the rollback of federal policies.

And it's kind of hard to say what comes next.

But I think, you know, I mean, for me, I guess the takeaway, which is a familiar one for our listeners, is just that, you know, if you think you've just solved the problem, right, by reducing suspensions, at a minimum, you need to look harder about what happens next and you need to think harder.

Because chances are it's spilling over in all sorts of ways.

Even if you have managed to solve one problem, you've almost certainly created some second-order problems that need considering.

Anyway, that is probably about as much as we can say about that today.

But thank you so much, Brian.

That was a good one.

Brian Fitzpatrick

Yeah.

Thanks so much for having me.

David Griffith

All right.

But that's all the time we have for today.

So until next time.

Brian Fitzpatrick

I'm Brian Fitzpatrick.

David Griffith

And I'm David Griffith of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, signing off.

Policy Priority:
Standards & Accountability
Topics:
Governance

President, Thomas B. Fordham Institute

Michael J. Petrilli is president of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, executive editor of Education Next, editor in chief of the Education Gadfly Weekly, host of the…

View Full Bio

David Griffith is the National Research Director at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, where he manages or authors reports on various subjects including charter schools, …

View Full Bio
Brian Fitzpatrick

Brian Fitzpatrick is the National Research Manager at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, where he conducts or manages research aimed at enhancing excellence for students and choice for families throughout the U.S K-12 education system. Prior to joining Fordham, he was a Senior Research Scientist at Gibson Consulting, where he worked with school districts to use data to improve instructional practices. This included authoring…

View Full Bio

Related Resources

view F grade
High Expectations

The myth of “mathematically inaccurate” grading

Adam Tyner, Ph.D. 11.17.2026
NationalBlog
view School funding narrative blog image
School Funding

The dishonest school funding narrative going around Ohio

Aaron Churchill 11.17.2026
OhioBlog
view Three things for Acton administration blog image
School Funding

Three ways Governor-elect Acton can keep her promise to help Ohio students reach their full potential

Jessica Poiner 11.16.2026
OhioBlog
Fordham Logo

© 2026 The Thomas B. Fordham Institute
Privacy Policy
Usage Agreement

National

P.O. Box 110
Burke, VA 22009

202.223.5452

[email protected]

Ohio

P.O. Box 82291
Columbus, OH 43202

614.223.1580

[email protected]

Sponsorship

130 West Second Street, Suite 410
Dayton, Ohio 45402

937.227.3368

[email protected]