Skip to main content

Mobile Navigation

  • National
    • Policy
      • High Expectations
      • Quality Choices
      • Personalized Pathways
    • Research
    • Commentary
      • Gadfly Newsletter
      • Flypaper Blog
    • Events
    • Scholars Program
  • Ohio
    • Policy
      • Priorities
      • Media & Testimony
    • Research
    • Commentary
      • Ohio Education Gadfly Biweekly
      • Ohio Gadfly Daily
  • Charter Authorizing
    • Application
    • Sponsored Schools
    • Resources
  • About
    • Mission
    • Board
    • Staff
    • Career
Home
Home
Advancing Educational Excellence

Main Navigation

  • National
  • Ohio
  • Charter Authorizing
  • About

National Menu

  • Topics
    • Accountability & Testing
    • Advanced Education
    • Career & Technical Education
    • Charter Schools
    • Curriculum & Instruction
    • ESSA
    • Evidence-Based Learning
    • Facilities
    • Governance
    • Personalized Learning
    • Private School Choice
    • School Finance
    • Standards
    • Teachers & School Leaders
    • Think Again
  • Research
  • Commentary
    • Gadfly Newsletter
    • Flypaper Blog
    • Gadfly Podcast
  • Events
  • Scholars Program
Flypaper

Opt-Out or Cop-Out? The great debate

Michelle Lerner Pamela Tatz
7.26.2013

A growing number of parents, educators, and school administrators are calling for a local "opt-out" from state tests and accountability systems. Mike Petrilli, Flypaper's own editor, is one of them; he is convinced that there are some schools, perhaps schools that are trying to do something different, that serve a unique population, or are high performing, that could benefit from the opt-out. After floating the opt-out idea in an exchange with Deborah Meier over at Education Week, he tested it out on some fellow ed reformers—and was told his opt-out was a cop-out.

So yesterday, the Thomas B. Fordham Insitute and Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) cohosted a lively discussion on the opt-out/cop-out, featuring Fordham's Mike Petrilli, DFER's Charles Barone, the Center on Reinventing Public Education's Robin Lake, the National Council of La Raza's Delia Pompa, and the National Association of Charter School Authorizers's Nelson Smith, with Bellwether's Andy Smarick moderating.

Twitter was alive with commentary. Here's the play-by-play.

Mike got it started by making a shocking revelation:

#Breaking: @MichaelPetrilli is a strong supporter of #CommonCore. #OptOrCop

— Fordham Institute (@educationgadfly) July 25, 2013

Then he outlined his idea:

@MichaelPetrilli would allow schools of choice to set their own rigorous standards. Affluent suburban schools too #OptOrCop

— Charlie Cummings (@CummingsCharles) July 25, 2013

Let's "let off some political steam" by letting 10% of schools opt out of state tests. - @MichaelPetrilli #OptorCop

— Marc Porter Magee (@marcportermagee) July 25, 2013

Charter school test scores on state tests aren't great but their college going rates are "through the roof" -@MichaelPetrilli #optorcop

— Ashley Inman (@ashleyemilia) July 25, 2013

Moderator Andy Smarick pushed it over to Charles Barone, but not without a little commentary of his own:

@smarick asks @CharlesBarone what's wrong with @MichaelPetrilli 10% idea at #OptorCop

— DFER (@DFER_News) July 25, 2013

The other panelists are skeptical.

"There's nothing in policy preventing schools from 'opting up' right now" @charlesbarone #optorcop

— NACSA (@QualityCharters) July 25, 2013
@RbnLake: I'm afraid that allowing schools to define their own accountability systems is a slippery slope #OptOrCop— Allie Kimmel (@allie_kimmel) July 25, 2013

"Schools can always present some reason why they shouldn't be closed." - @RbnLake #OptorCop

— Marc Porter Magee (@marcportermagee) July 25, 2013

Kids should always come first!! RT @marcportermagee: "Who are we worried about? Politicians or kids?" - Delia Pompa #OptorCop

— GLEP (@GLEP_MI) July 25, 2013

@NelsonSmith60 says with #CommonCore may diffuse some of the anti-testing sentiment #OptorCop

— DFER (@DFER_News) July 25, 2013

.@smarick: I have never seen an excellent school serving kids with lousy standardized test scores in reading and math #OptOrCop

— Allie Kimmel (@allie_kimmel) July 25, 2013

Mike got back up swinging:

.@MichaelPetrilli: "if states just want to look at student progress over time, we should allow that" #optorcop

— Ashley Inman (@ashleyemilia) July 25, 2013

"We need to be just as worried about mislabeling schools at the top as schools at the bottom." - @MichaelPetrilli #OptorCop

— Marc Porter Magee (@marcportermagee) July 25, 2013

Point by @MichaelPetrilli on making good schools look bad w/ tests true in OH for schools specializing in learning differences. #OptorCop

— OAIS (@OHIndepSchools) July 25, 2013

Charles Barone was full of witty comebacks:

@CharlesBarone - Learning algebra = not fun #optorcop

— DFER (@DFER_News) July 25, 2013

The deal was get rid of input measures in exchange for outcome measures. Now what? No measures? - @CharlesBarone #OptorCop

— Marc Porter Magee (@marcportermagee) July 25, 2013

Says @CharlesBarone: When you see a doctor and cholesterol is OK, doctor doesn't say "Great, come back in 10 years" #OptOrCop

— Pamela Tatz (@wishenough) July 25, 2013

The money moment:

Someone asks the teachers in the room to raise their hands; and almost the whole room does. That's #edreform! #OptorCop

— Michelle Gininger (@mgininger) July 25, 2013

So did Mike convince anyone to give his idea a shot?

Haha! RT @wishenough: When @smarick asks for a show of hands from the "Mike-is-crazy" camp: entire Fordham staff raises hands #optorcop

— Ashley Inman (@ashleyemilia) July 25, 2013

In the end,

Too many good points being made to quote. Just tune in to #OptorCop : http://t.co/s27xH6TbQD

— Tania de Sa Campos (@taniadsc) July 25, 2013


So did Mike convince you? Watch the event and let us know!

Tags: Democrats for Education Reform

Michelle Lerner was the communications director at the Thomas B. Fordham Institute.

Pamela Tatz is the Fordham Institute’s editorial associate, which affords her the dual privileges of managing the Education Gadfly publication and being the resident grammar czar; she has also worked as one of the office's hard-working research interns. Before joining Fordham, she studied political science and economics at Wayne State University, where her academic interests included…

View Full Bio
Fordham Logo

© 2026 The Thomas B. Fordham Institute
Privacy Policy
Usage Agreement

National

P.O. Box 110
Burke, VA 22009

202.223.5452

[email protected]

Ohio

P.O. Box 82291
Columbus, OH 43202

614.223.1580

[email protected]

Sponsorship

130 West Second Street, Suite 410
Dayton, Ohio 45402

937.227.3368

[email protected]