Editor's note: Last week's issue, especially the News and Analysis, generated a number of letters; we've included two, both from Minnesota.
I read Marty Davis's eloquent News and Analysis ("Premature judgment," June 8) about his son's kindergarten teacher, who said the boy "will always struggle in school." Marty, age 5 is far too early to know how a youngster will do for the rest of his/her time in school. The teacher's comment is outrageous.
As someone with three children, all now in their 20s, I can identify with the concerns you and your wife have. But as a parent, and a professional educator for more than 35 years, I know the impact a single negative, cruel teacher can have on a youngster.
I have a friend who was labeled as a struggling learner early in school, and felt dumb for years. It was not until he joined the Navy that he discovered he loved cooking. He was very good at it. He ended up owning and running an extremely successful restaurant, writing two books, and appearing often on television.
Best things that can happen for your youngest son are:
- You continue to encourage him by reading to him, by pointing out signs as you drive around in the community, and by travel;
- You ignore the teacher's outrageous comment;
- You help him find things he is good at, and enjoys.
Thanks again for sharing your family's story.
Joe Nathan, Director
Center for School Change
Humphrey Institute
University of Minnesota
